CHUCK SPY BANNER 2024 1.jpg

Pickers and Pilers by Jamie Kirkpatrick

IMG 8846

IMG 8846

She likes to pick crabs; I don’t. Don’t get me wrong: I have nothing against the feisty little crustaceans; I like them well enough in a creamy soup or an eponymous cake, but picking them? The juice just doesn’t seem worth the squeeze to me. I guess it’s just a Maryland thing, hon.

To me, picking crabs (or, in my case, peeling shrimp) is just an excuse; it’s finger-fiddling. Let’s be honest: isn’t the main point of a crab extravaganza really more about the butter and the beer, the fresh yellow corn and ripe red tomatoes, the juicy watermelon chaser? And, of course, picking crabs is not simply an exercise in eating and drinking—the stuff of sustenance. Picking crabs is just another excuse for friends to gather around a messy paper-covered table on a sunny summer afternoon to swap stories, tell jokes, or reminisce in good company. It’s how we honor each other.

At a crab feast, she knows exactly what to do: what to pound with a mallet, when to pry with a knife, how to rend with her fingers. I’m more of an outlier, an observer. I’m mesmerized by her manners and expertise, as well as by her savoir-faire in crab-related customs and strategies. For instance, at a recent gathering, I noted that most everyone at the table was a picker, but there was one person who was a “piler.” He didn’t immediately eat what he picked; Instead, he made a great pile of all his crabmeat, then devoured it when he was good and ready. It was a different way of doing business, a methodology that called for plenty of patience and a wary regard for his table neighbors who were eyeing his great stack of succulent meat like hungry cats ready to pounce on a mouse.

Which brings me to this thought: could it be that the world is made up of just two types of people: pickers and pilers? Pickers deal in getting things done quickly—the plunder and pillage approach to life. Eat it now; it won’t last til tomorrow. Pilers, on the other hand, are savers.They like to amass their wealth whether that wealth is counted in fancy guitars (that’s what this particular friend collects) or crabmeat. Pilers bide their time, waiting for just the right moment to enjoy the fruits (or crabmeats) of their labors. 

They say there is a science to picking a crab: a right way to do it. But I’ve come to the conclusion that crab-picking is more art than science. And pilers know that it’s about knowing the finer things in life must be savored before they’re consumed because (to paraphrase Joni Mitchell) you can’t appreciate what you’ve got if it’s already gone. 

I’ll never be a picker so I guess that leaves me with no choice: like the lone guest at our table, I’m a piler. Little by little, I’ll build my legacy, watching it grow until it either gets top-heavy and topples over, or it’s purloined by all those greedy pickers who don’t have the foresight to store up what they’ll need to make it to their next meal.

I’ll be right back.

AI Disclosure: The Spy and its writers may use artificial intelligence tools to support accuracy and clarity in our reporting.

Write a Letter to the Editor on this Article

We encourage readers to offer their point of view on this article by submitting the following form. Editing is sometimes necessary and is done at the discretion of the editorial staff. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to the Spy
Receive daily intelligence reports right to your inbox

0 1.jpg
  • 24 MCM 003 Spy Ad 05 03 2024 1.png
  • 24 MCM 003 Spy Ad 05 03 2024 2.png
  • 24 MCM 003 Spy Ad 05 03 2024 3.png
  • 24 MCM 003 Spy Ad 05 03 2024 4.png
  • 24 MCM 003 Spy Ad 05 03 2024 5.png
unnamed 1.jpg
Centreville Farmers Market promo copy.jpg
Ches College Aug 2022.jpg
Itchmed ad Aug 18 copy
WAD Spy 2026
Richard Graves 3 copy.jpg
Waterfowl Dec 2025 copy.jpg
MSO March 2026.png
GunstonGolfTourn 300x500 1 180x300 1.jpg
CBEC format 3 engage copy 1 180x300 1.jpg
BOHL June 2023 rev 1.jpg
Compass 4 1 180x300 2.jpg
Avalon May 2023 copy.jpg
YMCA Membership CENTREVILLE copy.jpg
Bay Woods March 2024 rule copy.jpg
Pediatrics Chestertown Ad Fall (300x500) MECH
CCHS resize copy.jpg
Adkins PFS Spy Ad 2026.jpg
Qlarant Spy ad 8 13 2025.jpg
unnamed.gif
Centreville Main St 300x500 copy.jpg
  • Centreville Farmers Market promo copy.jpg
  • Compass 4 1 180x300 2.jpg
  • Waterfowl Dec 2025 copy.jpg
  • WAD Spy 2026
  • CBEC format 3 engage copy 1 180x300 1.jpg
  • YMCA Membership CENTREVILLE copy.jpg
  • unnamed 1.jpg
  • Avalon May 2023 copy.jpg
  • Ches College Aug 2022.jpg
  • Chesapeake Forum Spy ad 5 14 26
  • unnamed.gif
  • MSO March 2026.png
  • Adkins PFS Spy Ad 2026.jpg
  • GunstonGolfTourn 300x500 1 180x300 1.jpg
  • Centreville Main St 300x500 copy.jpg
  • Camp26 300x500 respite
  • BOHL June 2023 rev 1.jpg
  • Pediatrics Chestertown Ad Fall (300x500) MECH
  • Richard Graves 3 copy.jpg
  • Qlarant Spy ad 8 13 2025.jpg
  • Waterfowl Dec 2025 copy.jpg
  • Camp26 300x500 respite
  • unnamed.gif
  • Bay Woods March 2024 rule copy.jpg
  • WAD Spy 2026
  • Compass 4 1 180x300 2.jpg
  • Centreville Main St 300x500 copy.jpg
  • GunstonGolfTourn 300x500 1 180x300 1.jpg
  • Adkins PFS Spy Ad 2026.jpg
  • MSO March 2026.png
  • Richard Graves 3 copy.jpg
  • BOHL June 2023 rev 1.jpg
  • YMCA Membership CENTREVILLE copy.jpg
  • Centreville Farmers Market promo copy.jpg
  • CBEC format 3 engage copy 1 180x300 1.jpg
  • Qlarant Spy ad 8 13 2025.jpg
  • unnamed 1.jpg
  • CCHS resize copy.jpg
  • Avalon May 2023 copy.jpg
  • Ches College Aug 2022.jpg